Their 2006 followup, Lake of Fire, was released on iTunes and then released in CD. It features songs by Van Morrison, The Waterboys and Ron Sexsmith. On October 8, 2007, Tara MacLean announced that she was leaving the trio. After MacLean's departure, Stockwood and Doyle announced on their website they would continue making music together as "Shaye". In 2009, Shaye's official website was redirected to MySpace where it was announced the band was officially no longer together. Kim Stockwood and Damhnait Doyle thanked their fans for all of their support.